When Weather Systems Cut Off: How South Africa's Most Unpredictable Storms Are Reshaping Insurance Risk | InsureAI Blog

As snow blankets parts of the Drakensberg and the Eastern Cape today, June 9th, South Africa finds itself once again in the grip of a cut-off low—one of the country's most destructive weather phenomena. The South African Weather Service issued impact-based warnings for disruptive snowfall over the Drakensberg and heavy rain in the Eastern Cape for June 8-9, 2025, highlighting the continued threat these systems pose. This latest system serves as a timely reminder of why these atmospheric anomalies have become a defining challenge for the nation's insurance industry, and how they compare to similar weather risks plaguing insurers worldwide.

The images emerging from today's weather event tell a familiar story: road closures due to unexpected snowfall, coastal communities bracing for flooding, and emergency services preparing for the inevitable aftermath. Yet behind this dramatic meteorological theatertheatre lies a more sobering reality, c—cut-off lows have fundamentally reshaped South Africa's insurance landscape, driving billions in claims and forcing the industry to completely reimagine how it approaches weather risk. This challenge mirrors similar disruptions occurring across the globe as different types of low-pressure systems wreak havoc on insurance markets from California's atmospheric rivers to Europe's explosive windstorms.

The Atmospheric Rebels That Defy Prediction

Cut-off lows differ notably from typical cold fronts, which move across the region in regular patterns. In contrast, cut-off lows separate from normal atmospheric flow, forming isolated pockets of cold air that may remain stationary over southern Africa for several days.

The science behind their formation reads like atmospheric drama. These systems begin as ordinary upper-level troughs embedded in the jet stream. Typically, through a process known as Rossby wave breaking, these troughs amplify and eventually separate from the main westerly flow. What emerges is a closed circulation system at mid-tropospheric levels, generally around 5 500 meters altitude, with a cold core surrounded by concentric rings of progressively warm air.

This formation mechanism distinguishes cut-off lows from other destructive weather systems around the world. European windstorms, for instance, are weather systems driven by temperature differences between cold and warm air masses. These storms typically move rapidly eastward at speeds of 80 kilometers per hour or more, often affecting entire countries rather than smaller regions. North American bomb cyclones rely on similar atmospheric processes but intensify dramatically when frigid continental air collides with warm ocean water. Their central pressure rapidly drops, by at least 24 hectopascals in 24 hours, leading to powerful storms. Meanwhile, hurricanes and typhoons represent an entirely different breed, warm-core heat engines that feed off 26°C ocean water and latent heat release, concentrating category-4 or 5 winds into tight eyewalls.

South Africa experiences approximately eleven cut-off lows annually (Taljaard 1985; Singleton & Reason 2007), with peak activity during the transitional months of March through May and September through November. Today's event in June, though somewhat unusual in winter, demonstrates the unpredictability that makes forecasting and risk assessment particularly challenging. The Eastern Cape Province bears the brunt of most cut-off low impacts, though as today's widespread snow and rain demonstrate, no region is entirely safe from their reach.

Cut-off lows contribute between 25 and over 35 percent of annual rainfall along South Africa’s south and east coasts (Favre et al., 2013), making them essential to the country's water security yet dangerous when they linger too long or intensify beyond normal parameters. The interaction between these systems and South Africa's complex topography, featuring steep coastal escarpments rising to high inland plateaus, creates a perfect storm for extreme weather. When moist air driven by a cut-off low meets these escarpments, it is forced upward, producing intense rainfall. In some cases, this can result in months’ worth of precipitation falling in just a few days.

A Global Perspective on Weather Catastrophes

South Africa's struggle with cut-off lows reflects a broader global challenge, as various weather systems place significant pressure on insurance markets worldwide. Each type of low-pressure system exhibits distinct characteristics in its formation, movement, damage patterns, and effects on actuarial assessments.

In the Mediterranean, hybrid storms called medicanes occasionally develop warm cores when sea surface temperatures are around 25 °C or higher, generating hurricane-like conditions in regions not built. Medicane Ianos in 2020 caused at least US $100 million in damage in Greece, demonstrating how even small systems can inflict major harm in densely populated coastal areas.

California and the Pacific Northwest face a different challenge entirely from atmospheric rivers — long, narrow plumes of water vapor that act like "skyborne fire hoses" when they stall against coastal mountains. Stanford researchers reported that clusters of atmospheric rivers striking in quick succession multiply damage three to four times beyond the sum of individual storms (Stanford News, 2024). This is because the ground becomes saturated and flood defences are overwhelmed, a pattern similar to what South African insurers observe with repeated cut-off low events.

European insurers face similar clustering challenges with explosive windstorms that can devastate multiple countries within days. In February 2022, a trio of storms (Dudley, Eunice, and Franklin) struck in rapid succession, resulting in estimated insured losses of €3.85 billion according to PERILS. Analysts at Moody’s highlight that this kind of clustering places significant strain on reinsurance schemes, which are often designed around the assumption of single, separate events.

Even the Arctic contributes to global insurance challenges through storms called polar lows — small, intense cyclones forming when cold air moves over warmer ocean waters. Although these storms usually occur far from populated areas, they significantly affect offshore oil and gas operations. Companies in this sector consider the downtime from polar lows a meaningful business-interruption risk, demonstrating how the consequences of severe weather go beyond traditional property damage.

A History Written in Insurance Claims

The insurance industry's relationship with cut-off lows reads like a catalog of catastrophes, each event adding another chapter to an increasingly expensive story. The April 2022 KwaZulu-Natal floods stand as the most devastating example in recent memory, when a cut-off low system delivered more than 200 millimeters across coastal KZN between April 8-12, including 304 millimeters in 24 hours at Virginia Airport. This event triggered what became South Africa's costliest flood on record, with industry-wide insured losses estimated at about US $1.5 billion (around R23 billion). Santam alone paid gross claims of R4.3 billion, marking the largest flood loss event in the company’s history.

The 2022 KwaZulu-Natal disaster was merely the latest in a long line of cut-off low catastrophes that have punctuated South African history with tragic regularity. The September 1987 KwaZulu-Natal floods delivered up to 900 millimeters of rainfall over five days, killing 506 people while causing about US $500 million (around R1 billion in 1987 terms) in damage. Similarly, the January 1981 Laingsburg flood demonstrated the deadly potential of these systems in unexpected locations, when a cut-off low delivered 425 millimeters of rainfall in 48 hours (to a town that normally receives just 175 millimeters annually) killing at least 104 people.

The compound nature of cut-off low disasters becomes clear when examining the Cape Storm of June 7, 2017. An intense cut-off low and associated surface cyclone slammed the Western Cape with nine-meter seas and gusts over 120 kilometers per hour. On its eastern flank, hot, dry berg winds stalled over the Garden Route, drying out vegetation.

Lightning then ignited fynbos and timber plantations, with gale winds fanning the flames into the Knysna firestorm that levelled nearly a thousand structures. The combined storm, flood, and fire claims pushed total insured losses well above R2 billion, demonstrating how cut-off lows can trigger cascading disasters across multiple perils.

The financial impact of cut-off low events goes far beyond these headline disasters. By the end of 2023, insurance payouts and operating costs in South Africa exceeded premium income, pushing the sector’s combined ratio to 100.6% (South African Reserve Bank data) — a signal of underwriting losses largely driven by extreme weather. In the first half of 2024, Santam paid out R607 million in weather-related claims, up from R150 million during the same period in 2023. Reinsurers observed this trend clearly, with property-catastrophe reinsurance rates in South Africa rising by as much as 40% during the 2024 mid-year renewals.

This pattern of increasing secondary peril losses (frequent, medium-sized events that erode combined ratios year after year) mirrors trends in other regions. European windstorms, atmospheric rivers, and cut-off lows all fall into this category, contrasting with tropical cyclones that dominate single-event insured-loss tables but come with mature models and dedicated reinsurance layers.

Climate Change: Amplifying an Already Dangerous Threat

The spectre of climate change looms large over South Africa's cut-off low risk landscape, introducing new layers of complexity and uncertainty to an already challenging phenomenon. South Africa's average land temperatures have warmed by just more than 1.0°C since 1960 (higher than the global average) transforming the atmospheric conditions that govern these systems . While specific research on climate change impacts on cut-off low frequency remains limited, the underlying physical mechanisms suggest significant alterations ahead.

Recent research indicates that intense, long-lasting cut-off lows may become more frequent in spring over land areas, raising the flood burden not only for South Africa but also for similar regions like Iberia and Australia. This finding aligns with broader global trends affecting other weather systems: warmer seas already appear to be fueling stronger hurricanes and more moisture-rich atmospheric rivers, while European windstorm clustering may intensify as jet-stream patterns change.

As the planet warms, the air can hold more moisture — about 7% more water vapor for every 1 °C rise. This extra moisture makes rain from cut-off lows more intense when they do occur. Climate models (CMIP6) suggest that under high-warming scenarios, South Africa may actually see 5 – 15% less average annual rainfall, but when storms happen, they could be far heavier and more extreme. This combination means cut-off lows could become less frequent overall, but far more devastating when they strike.

Studies by World Weather Attribution show that extreme events like the 2022 KwaZulu-Natal floods, once considered 1-in-40 year occurrences, have become 1-in-20 year events in the current warming climate. That means the flood is now twice as likely as it was before climate change began. This surge in frequency carries serious implications for how we design infrastructure, set insurance prices, and prepare for future disasters across South Africa.

The challenge is compounded by South Africa's complex relationship with global climate patterns. In La Niña years, these storms tend to appear more often and further north, leading to increased rainfall. During El Niño years, the systems usually stay too far south to bring much rain to the country. However, as the climate changes, these weather patterns may shift in ways we can't yet predict. That means both the frequency and location of cut-off low impacts could change, posing new challenges for forecasting and planning.

Technology Meets Meteorology: insureAI's Climate-Informed Approach

The intersection of meteorological complexity and insurance necessity has created unprecedented opportunities for technological innovation in risk assessment. At insureAI, we have developed sophisticated methodologies that directly address the cut-off low challenge by incorporating climate datasets into non-life pricing models, transforming abstract atmospheric science into actionable insurance intelligence.

Our approach recognizes that traditional actuarial methods, while robust for stable risk environments, struggle to capture the dynamic nature of weather risks in a changing climate. This challenge extends far beyond South Africa's borders, as insurers worldwide grapple with how to price risks from atmospheric rivers in California, medicanes in the Mediterranean, or bomb cyclones across North America. Each system presents unique forecasting challenges and hazard combinations that demand innovative modelling approaches.

Through extensive research and practical application, we have demonstrated that machine learning techniques can effectively handle large climate datasets, such as: global climate model outputs, satellite observations, and high-resolution weather station data. By integrating these data sources, we create pricing models that adapt to evolving risk patterns. The breakthrough lies in our ability to translate complex atmospheric variables into risk factors that traditional actuarial models can understand and apply.

For assessing cut-off low risks, our models incorporate readily available meteorological factors such as regional precipitation patterns and historical rainfall intensities. These variables, derived from historical weather station observations and climate reanalysis datasets spanning decades, provide the historical depth and meteorological sophistication necessary to price weather risks accurately.

The practical benefits of our approach go beyond theoretical insights. By utilizing machine learning methods, our models can detect and incorporate meaningful climate patterns that traditional methods may overlook. Examples include the influence of Indian Ocean temperature variations on cut-off low activity, or how broader climatic patterns may relate to regional weather risks in South Africa. Incorporating these insights allows insurers to adjust their pricing more dynamically and effectively, moving beyond reliance on historical claims data that may not fully represent evolving risks.

Innovation in Response: The Industry Adapts Globally

The insurance industry's response to escalating cut-off low losses has sparked a wave of innovation that extends far beyond traditional coverage models, mirroring similar adaptations occurring worldwide as insurers grapple with diverse weather challenges.

Parametric insurance solutions have emerged as a particularly promising approach to the rapid-onset, high-impact nature of cut-off low disasters. Unlike traditional insurance that requires damage assessments before payment, parametric products trigger automatic payouts when predefined meteorological thresholds are exceeded. Such as rainfall totals exceeding 200 millimeters in 48 hours as measured by weather stations or satellite data. This approach has found applications across various weather perils globally: California utilities use parametric triggers for atmospheric river events, while European insurers offer windstorm parametrics based on measured wind speeds.

Insurers are improving their catastrophe modeling capabilities to better capture cut-off low risk. By using detailed flood maps and high-resolution climate datasets, they can estimate potential losses under specific cut-off low scenarios. AI-enhanced tools also scan satellite and aerial imagery to flag at-risk properties, looking at things like roof condition and nearby vegetation, long before disaster strikes. Some policies now even include alert services, sending SMS warnings to clients about incoming severe weather and giving them time to secure assets or evacuate, offering peace of mind in a single package.

Forecasting the Future: Challenges and Opportunities

Despite improvements in weather forecasting, cut-off lows remain particularly difficult to predict. After these systems break away from the jet stream, they can meander unpredictably, making it challenging to accurately forecast where and how much rain will fall. In contrast, storms like European windstorms and North American bomb cyclones move faster and are tracked by well-equipped observation systems, making them easier to predict up to three days out. While hurricanes and typhoons can last about a week, their paths are now much easier to forecast thanks to satellites and improved forecasting techniques.

Numerical weather prediction models often struggle with cut-off lows because slight errors in locating these upper-level weather systems can translate into large errors in local rainfall placement. A 150-kilometer wobble in track can shift the flooding footprint by an entire district. This issue makes it very challenging to rely on precise forecasts for these storms, unlike predictions for many other types of weather systems.

Recent advances in high-resolution modeling and ensemble prediction systems offer some hope for improvement. The South African Weather Services uses detailed simulations that map weather every 1.5 to 4 km—these run several times a day to help pin down where storms might hit. The shift toward impact-based forecasting, focusing on expected consequences rather than just meteorological parameters, has improved risk communication for cut-off low events. When the Weather Service issues warnings highlighting expected flooding, infrastructure damage, and hail rather than simply predicting rainfall amounts, communities and insurers can prepare more effectively.

Ensemble prediction systems, which run multiple forecasts to handle uncertainty in cut-off low tracks, have shown more reliable predictions than single-model runs. This approach mirrors successful ensemble techniques used for hurricane track forecasting, where multiple model scenarios help quantify uncertainty and improve decision-making.

The insurance industry's adaptation to cut-off low risk reflects broader changes in how society manages weather-related risks in an era of climate change. The challenges posed by these systems—their unpredictability, their potential for extreme impacts, and their sensitivity to climate change—mirror those facing the global insurance industry as extreme weather events become more frequent and severe worldwide.

Conclusion: Preparing for an Uncertain Future

As today's cut-off low system continues its slow march across South Africa, bringing snow to mountain passes and causing heavy rains in the Eastern Cape, it serves as a powerful reminder of both the challenges and opportunities that define our relationship with extreme weather.

Globally, similar weather phenomena, from European windstorms and North American bomb cyclones to atmospheric rivers in California highlight a broader trend: weather-related disasters are becoming increasingly severe and frequent. The implications for insurers are profound, as escalating claims, rising reinsurance costs, and shifting climate patterns demand a proactive response.

The South African Reserve Bank’s recent announcement of climate-risk stress tests coming soon to the insurance industry underscores the importance of adopting forward-looking, climate-informed risk assessments. Deputy Governor Fundi Tshazibana emphasized, “We are going to progress [the climate-risk scenario stress test] to the insurance sector,” signaling a pivotal shift toward preparedness for climate-related financial impacts.

At insureAI, we recognize the importance of this transition. Our actuarial and machine learning methodologies help insurers integrate climate data into their risk assessments, translating complex meteorological variables into actionable pricing and underwriting insights. By employing these innovative techniques, insurers can better anticipate and respond to evolving climate risks, safeguarding their portfolios and enhancing community resilience.

As we navigate an uncertain climatic future, collaboration, innovation, and proactive adaptation will be critical. Stay warm and safe over the coming days—and remember, we're here to help insurers prepare for whatever weather comes next.

insureAI specializes in developing next-generation actuarial solutions, including non-life pricing models that incorporate climate science into insurance risk assessment. Our proprietary methodologies for integrating climate datasets into non-life pricing models help insurers navigate the evolving landscape of weather-related risks. To learn more about our climate-informed pricing capabilities, contact our team.

References:

Xulu et al. (2023). "Cut-Off Lows over South Africa: A Review." Climate, 11(3):59.
Aon (2023). Weather Catastrophes Highlight Perils of Underinsurance.
Farmers Weekly (2023). KZN farmers still reeling from April 2022 floods.
FA News (2023). "Flooding sinks insurer profits."
KPMG (2024). South African Insurance Industry Survey 2024.
Mishra et al. (2025). "Long-lasting intense cut-off lows to become more frequent in future climates." Communications Earth & Environment, 6:115.
PERILS (2022). "EUR 3.85bn PERILS releases final loss estimate for European Windstorm Series of February 2022."
Stanford News (2024). "Clusters of atmospheric rivers amp up California storm damages."
Aon (2023). South Africa Flood Event Recap: KwaZulu-Natal, April 2022. Aon Catastrophe Insight report, 20 pp.
Aon South Africa (2024). State of the Market Report 2024 – Reinsurance Market Update, pp. 34-37.
BusinessLIVE (11 January 2024). "Short-term insurance outlook for 2024: cautious optimism despite headwinds."
CSIR (2024). South African Climate Trends and Projections – 2nd Edition. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, Pretoria, 76 pp.
Favre, A. et al. (2013). "Cut-off lows in the South Africa region and their contribution to precipitation." Climate Dynamics, 41(9-10): 2331-2351.
IPCC (2021). Sixth Assessment Report, WG I, Chapter 12: Africa. Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change.
SA Reserve Bank Prudential Authority (2024). Selected South African Insurance Sector Data – December 2023, Table 4 ("Non-life combined ratio").
SA Weather Service (8 June 2025). Impact-Based Warnings for 9–10 June 2025: Disruptive Snow & Heavy Rain (Bulletin ID: COL-09-06-25).
SA Weather Service (2024). "Operational overview of the SA4 and SA1.5 Unified Model suites." Technical Note 2024-03.
Singleton, A. T. & Reason, C. J. C. (2007). "Variability in the characteristics of cut-off low pressure systems over subtropical southern Africa." International Journal of Climatology, 27: 295-310.
Stanford News (2024). "Clusters of atmospheric rivers amp up California storm damages." 17 April 2024.
Taljaard, J. J. (1985). Cut-Off Lows in the South Africa Region. South African Weather Bureau Technical Paper 14, 153 pp.
World Bank / EM-DAT (2024). South Africa Natural Disaster Loss Database – economic loss & people affected summary to 31 Dec 2024.
World Weather Attribution (2022). South-East Africa Floods, April 2022: Rapid Attribution Analysis, 12 pp.